Pros and Cons of Ergonomic Office Equipment
All "ergonomic" items have some drawbacks or possibilities for misuse.
This section explains some of the possibilities for office accessories and furniture.
Although this page has to do with stuff you can buy, keep in mind that many ergonomic problems can be fixed by rearrangement, adjustment or modification of existing items.
In this page:
"Purpose" means what the gizmo is supposed to correct. You may not need to correct whatever it is the gizmo's for, so you may not need to buy one.
"Misuse and Drawbacks" talks about how the gizmo can actually do harm, potentially. Everything can do harm, so this section is important.
"General End-User Instructions" speaks to the person who's going to use the gizmo. It talks about adjusting it and work habits. The "Instructions" section, or something like it, should be given IN WRITING to every recipient of that particular gizmo. Always.
"Choices" describes some of the options available out there in the marketplace --- some of the variations offered by various vendors. The main point of the "Choices" section is to get you to look beyond the one or two examples of a gizmo you have seen. There may be fancier and better versions.
This is a very long web page (about a dozen mortal pages). Here are shortcuts:
Keyboard trays |
Alternative keyboards |
| Keyboard Trays | |
Purpose: |
To adjust the height and angle of a keyboard in order to fit the person or allow posture change |
Possible Drawbacks or Misuse: |
The mechanism reduces knee clearance. |
General End-User Instructions: |
The purpose of this device is to adjust the
height and angle of the keyboard and mouse. The best height for the keyboard is generally
about at elbow height or lower, but nearly any height is acceptable if it is comfortable. |
Choices: |
Height adjustability is a critical feature in
most cases. Maintenance adjustability or fixed-height devices may be acceptable, if
keyboard use is light. |
| Wrist Rests | |
Purpose: |
To prevent the wrist from dropping (bending
back) while keying during keying pauses, or while mousing |
Possible Drawbacks or Misuse: |
A too-thick or too-high wrist rest can cause
forward flexion of the wrist. |
General End-User Instructions: |
When in use, the wrist rest should keep the
wrist straight rather than bent up or down. |
Choices: |
Thickness of the rest should be about the same
as the front of the keyboard. |
| Mouse Support Trays | |
Purpose: |
To reduce reaching by allowing a mouse to be used near the keyboard, if a keyboard tray is used. |
Possible Drawbacks or Misuse: |
Adding a mouse extension to many keyboard trays makes them feel unstable or jiggly. |
General End-User Instructions: |
The purpose of this device is to adjust the
height and angle of the mouse so the mouse can be used with a straight wrist. |
Choices: |
Mouse trays usually take the form of an
extension on a keyboard tray or a "breadboard" on a worksurface, but can be a
separate table or stand. |
| Forearm Supports | |
Purpose: |
To support the arms (take weight from the
shoulders). |
Possible Drawbacks or Misuse: |
Some users find they get in the way. |
General End- User Instructions: |
Forearm supports are often most comfortable if
they support the arm about midway between the wrist and the elbow. Find the position
that's best for you. |
Choices: |
Height adjustability is important to the comfort of most users. |
| Alternative Keyboards and Alternatives to Mice (see also alternative keyboards) | |
Purpose: |
To use different muscles during keying or mouse. |
Possible Drawbacks or Misuse: |
Some users find it difficult to adapt to new
keyboard shapes or mouse alternatives. Error rates usually increase and speed slows. Most
typists eventually return to their original accuracy and speed. |
General End-User Instructions: |
Get used to alternative devices slowly. If
discomfort develops, it may be due to the new design. Evaluate the situation carefully. |
Choices: |
For keyboards, current choices are split and/or
angled keyboards. |
| Height-adjustable tables and worksurfaces | |
Purpose: |
To fit different-size workers, or different
postures for the same workers. |
Possible Drawbacks or Misuse: |
Expense |
General End-User Instructions: |
Tables (and the work or equipment on them)
should be at a height where you can easily key with straight wrists and read or write
without either slumping forward too much or hunching up your shoulders. For most people,
keying and writing are done at different heights --- many people prefer a writing surface
that is a little higher than the typical keyboard surface. |
Choices: |
Height range (from a few inches to full
sit-stand range) should be matched to the situation. Generally, a person changing from
sitting to standing needs a maximum of 20 inches of height adjustability from their seated
elbow height to their standing elbow height. Also, a diverse group of seated people has
about a 5 inch difference between the lowest elbow height and the highest elbow height in
the group. |
| Monitor arms (See also viewing distance) | |
Purpose: |
To free up work surface under the monitor. |
Possible Drawbacks or Misuse: |
For many users, monitor arms put the monitor up higher than recommended (the top of the screen area should be no higher than eye height). An arm with keyboard storage can stress the back when lifting the keyboard onto its bracket. |
General End-User Instructions: |
The monitor arm can be used to bring the monitor forward and back when you change posture. |
Choices: |
Height and in-out range should be matched to the situation. In general, the lower the monitor can be held, the better. |
| Glare screens | |
Purpose: |
To improve screen visibility by reducing bright spots or washout caused by ambient light on monitor screens. |
Possible Drawbacks or Misuse: |
Mesh screens can collect dust and obscure the image Optically coated ("anti-glare coating") screens can be difficult to keep clean. |
General End-User Instructions: |
Once the glare screen is installed, increase the brightness of the monitor as necessary to compensate for any darkening caused by the glare device. |
Choices: |
Mesh, polarized, optically coated. Screens that are both polarized and optically coated cause much less distortion than mesh screens. Polarized screens are not very effective when used over a monitor with frosted or etched glass There are different grades of optical coatings. In general, a purplish (rather than green or blue) reflection is the best quality. Screens that fit more than one monitor size are more versatile in the long run. |
| Document stands | |
Purpose: |
To reduce distortion of print that happens when a document is slanted away from the eyes. |
Possible Drawbacks or Misuse: |
Freestanding types can sometimes get in the way. |
General End-User Instructions: |
Angle the document stand to aim the copy straight toward your eyes. It should be as close to the side of the monitor as possible, to minimize looking from side to side. The document should be at about the same distance from your eyes as the monitor is (assuming the monitor is at a good, readable distance). There is little evidence regarding whether the document should be at the same height as the monitor, but a too-high document (or monitor) can cause neck and shoulder tension. |
Choices: |
Size and weight capacity should be matched to the documents used Method of mounting (base, articulating arm, monitor attachment) affects usability Depending on needs, the user may prefer a stand that can easily be moved out of the way. People who flip pages frequently may dislike a stand that has a lip along the bottom edge Some people may prefer a line guide, and people working from columns of numbers often need a line guide that moves by the action of a foot pedal. |
| Task lights (see also visual ergonomics) | |
Purpose: |
To reduce eyestrain or "peering" postures by illuminating paperwork and reducing the need for bright ambient light that may cause screen glare or increase the contrast between the screen and its surroundings. |
Possible Drawbacks or Misuse: |
Some task lights in some situations can cause glare on the screen, can shine directly into workers' eyes, or can illuminate the area around and behind the monitor too brightly. Different people need or prefer different lighting levels. Task lights without dimmers may not meet individuals' needs. |
General End-User Instructions: |
Use task lights to illuminate documents while avoiding illuminating the screen or the area around the screen. The task light bulb should not be visible to you when you are in your normal working position. If it is, shield the bulb or move the fixture. |
Choices: |
Lights on movable arms provide more flexibility in the location and even the quantity of light |
| Footrests | |
Purpose: |
To allow different positions or movement of the legs and feet. |
Possible Drawbacks or Misuse: |
Footrests are often used to compensate for a chair that is too high, substituting for more appropriate measures such as lowering the chair and/or worksurface. In these situations, footrests do support the legs but do not allow a full range of leg postures and the individual may find it difficult to move around the office while seated. |
General End-User Instructions: |
Change foot position often. Stretch out your legs, tuck them under the chair, move them from side to side. Use the footrest to put your feet up from time to time. As long as you don't feel unstable or cramped, most foot positions are fine. |
Choices: |
Footrests can have different degrees of adjustability, motion, and texture. |
| Adjustable seating (see also ergonomic chairs) | |
Purpose: |
To fit different workers, or different postures for the same worker. |
Possible Drawbacks or Misuse: |
Adjustments can be confusing without instructions No single chair is preferred by all users; many chairs and chair features can be uncomfortable Size extremes (very small or large people) are virtually ignored by the seating industry. There are only three or four office chairs appropriate for these people. |
General End-user Instructions: |
All adjustments and their purpose should be explained to the end user and posted in a central place. General adjustment procedures are explained in the following section. |
Choices: |
Multitudinous. Many adjustments are on the market: backrest up-down, backrest in-out, backrest angle, armrest up-down, armrest in-out, seat up-down, seat angle (including forward tilt on some models), lumbar support depth, type of seat height mechanism, tilt lock, tilt tension, type of recline (knee tilt, column tilt), etc. Each adjustment can have its own character: range, ease of adjustment, stiffness. |